Anubhuti Monga1, Narinder Verma2, O. P. Monga3
1School of Management Studies, Indira Gandhi National Open University, New Delhi
2Associate Professor & Director Special Projects, Faculty of Management Sciences & Liberal Arts, Shoolini University of Biotechnology and Management Sciences, Bajhol, Po. Sultanpur, Solan (H.P.) India
3Professor and Associate Dean, Faculty of Management Sciences & Liberal Arts, Shoolini University of Biotechnology and Management Sciences, Bajhol, P. O. Sultanpur, District Solan (H P), India
Correspondence to: O. P. Monga, Professor and Associate Dean, Faculty of Management Sciences & Liberal Arts, Shoolini University of Biotechnology and Management Sciences, Bajhol, P. O. Sultanpur, District Solan (H P), India.
Copyright © 2015 Scientific & Academic Publishing. All Rights Reserved.
The main focus of this study was to examine the level of job satisfaction of employees of the ICICI bank in their organizational context. A convenient sample of employees at selected six branches of the ICICI bank in the state of Himachal Pradesh was used. It comprised of eighty employees. A five point Likert Scale questionnaire containing fifteen questions extracted from the short form of Minnesota Satisfaction Questionnaire (MSQ) was administered for data collection. Besides, questions on personal characteristics, the questionnaire included important dimensions of organizational structure. The results obtained from analysis of data revealed that salary, inter-personal relationship, communication, attitude of superiors, working conditions and team work have more bearing than the factors of training and development, rewards and compensation, nature of job, job security, morale and role clarity in determining job satisfaction of employees of the ICICI bank in Himachal Pradesh. Some suggestions for further research and improving were also made.
Keywords: Job Satisfaction, Morale, and Organizational Environment
Cite this paper: Anubhuti Monga, Narinder Verma, O. P. Monga, A Study of Job Satisfaction of Employees of ICICI Bank in Himachal Pradesh, Human Resource Management Research, Vol. 5 No. 1, 2015, pp. 18-25. doi: 10.5923/j.hrmr.20150501.03.
- Historically, roots of the study of job satisfaction lie in the Hawthorne studies conducted during 1924-1933 and credited to Elton Mayo of the Harvard Business School. These studies culminated into “Hawthorne Effect” which states that changes in work conditions temporarily increase productivity. This marked the beginning to investigate factors of job satisfaction. In addition to this, Taylorism of Frederick Taylor (1911) popularly known as ‘scientific management’ also become the source of studies on job satisfaction. For the last two decades, the employees’ job satisfaction has been a focus of research and practice. It is considered to be a critical issue in organizational performance. It continues to be rhetoric in the minds of scholars and management practitioners, because of two questions: first, to what extent, job satisfaction is determined by personal and social variables? Second, to what extent organizational variables could be the building -blocks of job satisfaction? Job satisfaction is generally, understood an attitude towards one’s job. It simply indicates one’s contentment with the job. The most accepted meaning in literature, according to Cranny et. al. (1992) is the degree to which one enjoys doing his /her job. Sharma (2005) in his study of school teachers in Himachal Pradesh revealed that they were satisfied with their work, working conditions, salary structure, job security, promotional policies, institutional plans and policies, relationship with their co-workers, functioning of authorities (head) and their compatibility. Asondariya and Kumar (2008)inSaurashtra region and Kutch district in the state of Gujarat. found that except joint family, variables, namely: age, gender, education, caste, marital status are not significantly associated with Job Satisfaction of school teachers, Kumar and Garg (2010) in Punjab state of this country, reported that enhancement in salary, facilities and promotion leads to an increase in one’s job satisfaction.Abbas (2011) reported that financial factors, working conditions, supervision and advancement opportunities are associated with the overall satisfaction of the banking professionals. Archana Singh et al. (2011)reported that factors namely, pay, job interest, leadership, career growth, working environment, job responsibility etc. serves as stimulators for employee satisfaction in technology sector.Deshwal (2011)also found that the factors named as working conditions, organizational policies, independence, promotion opportunities, work variety, creativity, compensation, work itself, colleagues’ cooperation, responsibility, social status of job, job security, achievement and students’ interaction were associated with job satisfaction.Jagannathan and Sunder (2011)in their studyof employees of the Life Insurance Corporation of India in Tamil Nadu reported that the job security, recognition for work, supervision, pay, grievance handling procedures and other financial facilities had significant impact on their job satisfaction. Shariq (2011) in study of the impact of gender and attitude in banking professionals observed that female employees showed less satisfaction as compared to male respondents.Soumendu Biswas (2011) reported that psychological climate proved to be a significant positive predictor of job satisfaction. It further underscores that support and sincerity in supervisor-subordinate and peer-related relationships enhance an individual’s level of job satisfaction. Wadhwa et al. (2011)reported that factors of working conditions, fair rewarding, promotion opportunities, salary, adequate authority, supervisors influence the job satisfaction of employee.Shallu Sehgal (2012)her study of private and public sector banks employees in Shimla district of Himachal Pradesh indicated that socio-economic variable, such as, age, sex, and income were significantly correlated with job satisfaction of employees. The researcher reported that employees in old age group category were more satisfied than others. Aarti et al. (2013) identified factors, namely: salary of employees, performance appraisal system, promotional strategies, employee’s relationship with management and other co- employees, training and development program, work burden and working hours important for improving job satisfaction of the Canara Bank employees. Suman Devi and Suneja (2013) witnessed that significant difference exists between employees of public and private sector banks in various aspects of job satisfaction, pay and fringe benefits, supervision, training and development. But these differences are not significant in case of the aspects, in relation to co-workers, employee’s empowerment, supervision, performance appraisal and nature of job.Usop et. al. (2013)carried out a study on work performance and job satisfaction of 200 teachers of 12 selected public schools in the Cotabato city of Philippines. They reported that school policies, supervision, pay, interpersonal relations, opportunities for promotions and growth, working conditions, work itself, achievement, recognition, and responsibility were significantly associated with job satisfaction of teachers. Vikram Jeet and Sayeeduzzafar (2014) in their study on ‘HRM Practices and its Impact on Employees Job Satisfaction in Private Sector Banks’ reported that HRM practices like training, performance appraisal, team work and compensation have significant impact on job satisfaction of employees.From the above it becomes clear that studies on job satisfaction of bank employees are sporadic in nature. There seems one study (Shallu Sehgal, 2012) reported form Himachal Pradesh. Hence, differential nature of samples, groups and regions, provides a ground for more researches on job satisfaction of employees of banking sector in the state of Himachal Pradesh. Rationale of the studySince the Hawthorne studies in early twentieth century (1924-1933), job satisfaction continues to occupy the center stage of debate in academic circles and the world of work. In today’s technologically dynamic world, it has acquired added significance, not only, due to newer and multiple demands of the job, but also changing expectations of individuals from their job or work. Attrition, retention, recruitment, training, growth and development of employees, all converge directly or indirectly into the domain of job satisfaction Hence, understanding job satisfaction, is crucial, for effective management of diverse human resource, in the private and the public sector.The modern era is marked by a cut-throat competition in the market place. The market situations, technology, labour, work environment, and work culture are changing very rapidly. Hence, one’s survival in market may depend on skilled, knowledgeable, committed, hard working and satisfied employees. To retain existing and attracting potential candidates having high dedication towards work is the key to success for any organization including the banking sector. The need for such studies also stems from the fact that organizations try to devise effective mechanisms to make work environment congenial for employees. Such studies help organizations to devise ways to motivate employees to inculcate belongingness and improve health of organization. Banks like many other organizations are also faced with resistance to change, rewards, promotion policies, working conditions etc. Sporadic agitations by banking employees are indicative of the fact that understanding satisfaction of employees is very vital. The scope of this extends to all aspects of working environment and across various categories of employees within and outside banking organizations.
2. Statement of Problem
- In private sector, the ICICI Bank has emerged as one of the giant commercial bank in India. It is India's largest private sector bank with total assets of Rs. 5,946.42 billion (US$ 99 billion) on March 31, 2014. The Bank has a network of 3,753 branches and 11,336 ATMs in India, and has a presence in 19 countries, including India. The ICICI bank has witnessed tremendous change in terms of human resource, technology intervention and changing nature job in the context of market demands. From the point of view of human resource, it is characterized by workforce diversity, modern technology & automation and distinct organizational culture. In situation of diversity across age, gender, ethnic group, physical ability/disabilities, race and sexual orientation; more and more women joining business organizations as managers and other specialists; special recruitment programmes being conducted to recruit members belonging to scheduled castes/tribes, physically handicapped, ex-servicemen, retired employees; and the number of knowledge workers increasing day-by-day, understanding job satisfaction becomes crucial. This is because, persons with differential characteristics may perform differently and may exhibit differential level of job satisfaction. Thus, two important issues emerge: (1) are employees of the ICICI bank satisfied with their job? , and (2) to what extent organizational factors determine their satisfaction?Besides this, in new technological environment, the issue of employee satisfaction with their job, acquires an added significance due to diversity in terms of technology, manufacturing process, nature of job, division of work requires specialized knowledge and skills to perform a particular job. As these are not evenly distributed, may affect differentially performance of the workers. New technological advancements, based on artificial intelligence, are becoming common phenomena in the industrial world. Technology influences social situation, that is, the size of groups, membership of groups, patterns of interpersonal interactions, opportunity to control activities in a variety of ways. Hence, technology also affects human behavior considerably both within and outside organizations. For example, Jack D. Douglas (1971), a noted sociologist, comments that “because technology increasingly shapes almost every realm of our everyday life, and through formal education has increasingly become the dominant form of our modern thought, it could transform or destroy the social foundations of our most cherished human values. But it can’t ignore that technology has enhanced the speed of processing and production. Using advance technology provides a competitive edge to an organization over their competitor in the market. So, to sum up, it can be said advanced technology also needs human minds to handle it or to work with it. It becomes important to know, whether employees are comfortable with the use of technology or in other words, do they enjoy working with new technology?Another major dimension is the organizational structure. It is a source of satisfaction to people. Since it provides relatedness among tasks and responsibilities, and among people who work for an organization, sooner or later come to evaluate the nature of those relationships and of their jobs. Organization structure provides a place of status for each person which confers certain standing among his/her fellows. This works as motivating factor for them.The banking sector has been restructuring its organization design, policies, structure, working conditions etc., to meet new demands and to enhance the productivity of the employees. Not only this, the ICICI bank like many other private banks has adopted measures to provide congenial environment to its employees, better career opportunities and welfare to keep their morale high. It is not out of context to say that one’s perception of organizational structure may vary depending upon personal attributes and orientations, and therefore, employees may exhibit differential level of motivation. Hence, another important question emerges, to what extent employees are satisfied with the organization structure? In this background the present study entitled, ‘A study of Job Satisfaction of Employees of ICICI Bank in Himachal Pradesh’ was conducted. The main focus of this study was to assess the job satisfaction of bank employees in the context of organizational factors.
- This study was carried out with the following objectives;• To assess the level of job satisfaction of employees of the ICICI bank.• To identify organizational factors contributing towards the job satisfaction of employees of ICICI bank.Scope of the studyThe present study aims to assess the level of job satisfaction of the employees of the ICICI Bank, a private commercial bank in the state of Himachal Pradesh. It covers employees working in the ICICI bank. The employees belong to different categories such as officers, clerical staff and sub-staff. The study explores level of job satisfaction among employees working in the the ICICI Bank and examine it in organizational context, such as, rewards, promotion policies, working conditions, career development, inter-relationships etc., which affect job satisfaction. motivation. Hence, another important question emerges, to what extent employees are satisfied with the organization structure? Above all, it can be said, that job satisfaction is very important for the individual and as well as an organizational concern. In today’s world of work imbued with diversity in human resource, technological interventions, changing nature of job, differential expectations, new management practices, demands for specialized skills etc., the success and growth of any organization, to a great extent, depends on the satisfaction of employees. In this phase when employee’s expectations are not met by the organization and vice versa then various disputes take place. These disputes may cause loss of workforce, wages and production. This is also true to the banking sector.
- This ex-post facto approach was considered most suitable to understand the phenomenon of job satisfaction of employees of the ICICI bank. There are eighteen branches of the ICICI bank spread over ten districts in the state of Himachal Pradesh. The population of the study consisted of all employees who are working in ICICI bank in the state of Himachal Pradesh. A convenient sample of employees at selected six branches of ICICI bank, located at Nahan and Paonta in District of Sirmour, Baddi and Solan in District Solan and Kasumpti and Shimla in district Shimla was used. The sample consisted of eighty employees (Management Executives 20; Official Staff 40; and Supporting Staff 20). Those employees who are permanent and had two years of working experience were selected. The unit of the study was an employee in ICICI bank.The instrument for data collection was questionnaire. The first part consisted of questions about personal information on age, gender, education, marital status etc., and the second part had fifteen questions extracted from the short form of Minnesota Satisfaction Questionnaire (MSQ). These questions included important dimensions of organizational structure. These are: salary/compensation, training and development, flexibility, communication, work life balance, security, interpersonal relationships, decision-making, welfare measures, reward and recognition, attitude of employees, role clarity and morale of employees, working conditions, team work, promotion policies etc. Spector (1997) identified the 20-item short form of the Minnesota Satisfaction Questionnaire (MSQ) (Weiss et al., 1967) as a popular measure that is frequently used in job satisfaction research. One advantageous feature of the MSQ short form is that it can be used to measure two distinct components: intrinsic job satisfaction and extrinsic job satisfaction. Intrinsic job satisfaction refers to how people feel about the nature of the job tasks themselves; extrinsic job satisfaction refers to how people feel about aspects of the work situation that are external to the job tasks or work itself (Spector,1997). The reliability coefficient value of MSQ short form ranges from 0.87 to 0.97 and its validity is considered adequate. Each question had five response categories i.e., Very Satisfied, Satisfied, Neutral, Dissatisfied, and very Dissatisfied and allotted score as 5,4,3,2,1, respectively. We depended on the reliability and validity of the instrument as indicated in original manual of MSQ. Interviews were conducted on the selected respondents and the questionnaire was administered to them. The data was analysed using frequency and percentages, and to draw meaningful findings.ObservationsThe statistical data in terms of gender, education, marital status, work experience and respondents’ designation, monthly income of eighty employees of the ICICI banks in three districts of Himachal Pradesh are presented in Table No. 1. From the table, it can be pointed out that there was preponderance of males with significantly more than half of the respondents i.e. 66.25 per cent. A little more than half (53.75 %) of them were graduates. A little more than half (56.25%) were married. The proportion of respondents with income between Rs. 2500 t0 35000/- was highest (33.75%). Those with work experience 21 years and above were represented highest (37.50 %) and those with less than 10 years of experience also had the same proportion (37.50%). Half of the respondents were from office cadre staff.
|Figure 1. Summary of findings|
- After the analysis of statistical data and findings arrived, it can be concluded that employees in the ICICI bank in Himachal Pradesh nurture differential level of satisfaction across organizational variables, such as, salary/ compensation, training and development, the nature of job, work life balance, colleagues relationship, job security, chain of communication or relationships, decision-making, welfare measures, rewards and recognition, attitude of superiors, roles of the employees, working conditions, team work promotion policies etc. On the face of statistical findings, difference in percentage between satisfaction and dissatisfaction suggests that factors of salary, inter-personal relationship, communication, attitude of superiors, working conditions and team work are more significant in determining job satisfaction of employees of the ICICI bank in Himachal Pradesh. It can be pointed out that improvement in organizational variables, most particularly, in performance appraisal system, promotional strategies, position status and related rewards etc., may enhance job satisfaction and morale of employees in the ICICI bank.
- On the basis of above findings of the study, a few suggestions are put forward, and if followed by the ICICI bank, may help in enhancing job satisfaction among its employees.1. The conclusion mentioned above should be understood as indication. This is because, for drawing conclusions, more studies of this nature and on controlled and large samples are needed.2. The ICICI bank should suitably reward initiatives and contributions of employees. They must be recognized given adequate incentives to outstanding employees.3. Promotion involves higher responsibilities and therefore promotion policies should be effectively implemented as this forms an effective reward for commitment, loyalty and long service.4. Working conditions in terms of flexibility, workload and working hours should be tuned in such a way that they do not serve as barriers in maintaining work life balance which is essential for individual and social development.5. Seniors should inculcate positive attitude towards their subordinates in helping them to perform assigned tasks with increased efficiency and in turn learn comfortably with cooperation of others.6. The ICICI bank should further strengthen team building and team work backed by proper communication channel.
7. Limitations of the Study
- The present study had some limitations. These are as follows:• The data collected is based on questionnaire which was given to employees. It was very difficult to get back the filled up questionnaire as the bank employees were very busy even after business hours in their work spot.• Due to lack of time and resources, the study was confined to ICICI banks in Himachal Pradesh and on a small sample of 80 employees. All employees, irrespective of their position have been treated as homogenous group.• The ICICI bank employees are very busy and have little time to spare for off the job assignment and therefore might not have given correct answers. Some others might have hesitated to give the actual data due to fear of management or they merely thought it was a waste of time.• The findings and conclusions are based on knowledge and experience of the respondents which sometime may be biased.• Neutral responses on different dimensions ranged between 10-29 per cent.• Based on statistical results mentioned above, it becomes clear that all the factors of organizational culture influence job satisfaction of employees working in branches the work are more significant in determining job satisfaction of employees of the ICICI bank in Himachal Pradesh. The proportion of satisfied employees on these parameters ranged between 50 to 70 percent.
|||Aarti Sharma, (2013). Job satisfaction among bank employees. International Journal of Scientific and Technology Research, Vol.2, Issue 8.|
|||Abbas .S.M Shariq (2011). Banking professionals and attitudinal dimensions of job satisfaction: A descriptive study. International Journal of Research in Commerce, I.T, and Management. Vol. 1, Issue 6.|
|||Adam, J.A. (1963).”Towards and understanding of Inequality”. IN Singh Kavita 2009. Organizational Behaviour: Text and Cases. New Delhi: Pearson, PP.143-145.|
|||Annierah Maulana Usop (2013) Work performance and job satisfaction among teachers. International Journal of Humanities and Social Science. Vol.3, No.5, pp. 245-252.|
|||Archana Singh (2011) An enhancing productivity and performance of the employees by exploring employee satisfaction: an efficacious tool for it sector in India. International Journal of Management in Education, Vol.1, Issue5, pp.20-30.|
|||Asondariya, Dipeshkumar D., (2008) A study of achievement motivation, adjustment and job satisfaction of Vidyasahayak teachers of Saurashtra Kutch. Thesis Ph.D, Saurashtra University.|
|||Aswathappa, K. (1996). Organizational Behavior, Third Revised Himalaya Publishing House, Bombay, India, Pp.140-141.|
|||Brannigan, A. and Zwerman, W. (2001), The Real Hawthorne Effect, Society, 38(2):55.|
|||Cranny, C. J., Smith, P. C., and Stone, E. F.(1992). Job Satisfaction: How People Feel About Their Jobs and How It Affects Their Performance. New York :Lexigton Books.|
|||Deshwal Pankaj (2011) Job satisfaction: A study of those who mould the future of India. Global Conference on Innovations in Management at London, United Kingdom, pp. 164-172.|
|||Douglas,J. D. (1971). The Technological Threat. Englewood Cliffs, N.J., Prentice Hall, pp. 7-20.|
|||Ellickson. M. C. and Logsdon, K. (2002). Determinants of job satisfaction of municipal government employees. Public Personnel Management, Vol. 31, Issue 3, pp. 343-358.|
|||Gupta S P (2007), Statistical Tools and Techniques, GK publications.|
|||Haddock, P. (2010). Importance of morale. Retrieved September 10, 2014 from: http://www.ehow.com.|
|||Hoppock, R. (1935,). Job Satisfaction. New York,: Harper& Row.|
|||Jagannathan, R. and Sundar K. (2011) Job satisfaction among the employees of life insurance corporation of India Vellore division, Tamil Nadu, India. International Journal of Current Research, Vol.3, Issue 9, pp. 157-164.|
|||Korman AK, Greenhaus JH, Badin IJ. 1977Personnel attitudes and motivation. Annu.Rev. Psychol. 28:175–96.|
|||Locke, E.A. (1969). What is Job Satisfaction? Organizational Behaviour and Human Performance, 4, 309-336.|
|||Mazin R (2010). The effects of high morale on employee performance. Available: http://www.ehow.com [2010, May, 20].|
|||Navdeep Kumar and Pankaj Garg (2010) Impact of motivational factors on employee’s job satisfaction- A study on some selected organization in Punjab, India. Asian Journal of Management Research. Vol.2, No.1, pp. 672-683.|
|||Nidhi Punj (2013). Job satisfaction: Biggest challenge faced by HRD. Radix International Journal of Economics and Business Management, Vol.2, Issue 8, August 2013, pp.1-6.|
|||Sadia Shaheen (2014). Job satisfaction among male and female employees in public sector organizations. European Journal of Business and Management, Vol.6, No.4.|
|||Shallu Sehgal (2012) Job satisfaction of bank employees in Shimla, International Journal of Marketing, Finance Services and Management Research. Vol.1, Issue 7, pp. 124-146.|
|||Soumendu Biswas (2011) Psychological Climate as an Antecedent of Job Satisfaction & Job Involvement. Indian Journal of Industrial Relations,46(3):465-477.|
|||Suman Devi and Suneja, Ajay (2013) Job satisfaction among bank employees: A comparative study of public sector and private sector banks. International Journal of Research in Management and Technology. Vol. 1, No.2.|
|||Spector, P E (1997). Job satisfaction: Application,assessment, causes,and consequences. Thousand Oaks: Sage.|
|||Vikram Jeet and Sayeeduzzafar (2014). A study on HRM practices and its impact on employees job satisfaction in private sector banks: A case study of HDFC bank. International Journal of Advance Research in Computer Science and Management Studies. Vol.2, Issue 1: 62-68.|
|||Wadhwa, D. S., Verghese, M and Wadhwa D. S. (2011). A Study on Factors Influencing Employee Job Satisfaction-A Study in Cement Industry of Chhattisgarh. International Journal of Management & Business Studies, 1 (9):109-110.|
|||Weiss, D.J., Dawis, R.V., England, G.W., & Lofquist, L.H. (1967). Manual for the Minnesota Satisfaction Questionnaire. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota.|
|||www.icicibank.com ( Retrieved on 1st June, 2014)|
|||www.google.com (Retrieved on 8th Tune, 2014)|
|||www.scribd.com Retrieved on 1st July, 2014)|
|||www.wikipedia.com Retrieved on 28th August, 2014)|
|||http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frederick_Winslow_Taylor (retrieved on 3rd October 2014)|